The Iglesia de San Jose (St. Joseph's Church) was built soon after the original city was established in 1519. It featured a beautiful golden altar as its centerpiece. It soon became one of Panama's most valued treasures and a coveted dream for pirates and other thieves of the period. The altar is actually made out of hand-carved wood, but it is covered entirely in gold.
When word got out to European pirates about this beautiful golden altar that was being kept in the new city of Panama, an English pirate by the name of Henry Morgan was particularly interested in this magnificent treasure and set out to get it.
A lone priest by the name of Juan hatched a plan to preserve Panama’s golden altar. The main parts of the altar were disassembled, and it is said that the golden columns and altar tables were taken out into the bay and submerged. The rest of the altar could not be moved so priest Juan, along with other townspeople prepared a paint mixture made up of mud and black oil, and worked all night to cover the altar in order to somehow disguise it and protect it from the coming pirates.
As Morgan entered Panama City plundering, pillaging and burning, the inhabitants fled into the jungle, but priest Juan remained behind, determined to protect the church.
The pirates ran thru the city in the early morning hours of January 18, 1671, taking whatever they could find and killing those who stood in their way. Increasingly frustrated because he could not find the golden altar he so vehemently sought, Henry Morgan stepped into the church where he saw an old priest by a black altar and asked where was all the gold, jewels and the golden altar hidden.
Priest Juan surrendered a few pieces of gold, a chalice and some crosses then replied that other than this black altar made with wood and Panamanian mud, they were too poor to have much else of value.
They, he also said, needed money to finish their altar and since he had given him some of the church's possessions, wouldn't it be fair that he -Morgan- would at least give him some much needed money to finish the altar since now they had nothing else to bargain with?
Morgan is supposed to have said to priest Juan, "I don't know why, but I think you are more of a pirate than I am..."
It is said that the pirate then, reached into his own pocket, gave the priest a few silver coins and left in a very sour mood.